The 10-Step Guide to Fixing the Writer Website Fails That Cost You Clients
Carol Tice | 46 Comments

Fix your freelance writer website fails. Makealivingwriting.comIn Freelance Writers Den, I review a lot of writer websites. To sum up a lot, most of them don’t do a great job of selling that writer’s gifts. The sites have basic design or usability problems that are a real turnoff for clients.

Today, I thought I’d share some of the biggest problems that I see over and over again. These are fundamental flaws that really send prospects running screaming away from your site. I’m ranking them in order of how big a problem they are, with the biggest one at the top.

  1. No site. This of course is the most basic fail, and plenty of writers are still in this boat. If you don’t have a site it’s like you’re invisible at this point, especially to online markets. You just can’t compete for the good-paying gigs. To me, it’s a little crazy to go along with no site when you could join NAIWE and have a decent-looking WordPress portfolio site and blog up and ready to go by later today.
  2. No contacts visible. Too many writers still have only a contact tab — and when you go to that page, there’s only that horrid fill-in contact form that no one wants to fill out. Remember, the most important thing you want visitors to do is email or call and hire you. So you want to make that easy, with your real contact info visible on every page via a sidebar widget right at the top.
  3. Unhelpful headline and tagline. These two elements of your website are super-important, for two reasons — 1) they help search engines send you clients, if you fill them with key words about the type of writing you do and where you are; and 2) they help orient new arrivals in the 5 seconds or so you’ve got before they decide the site isn’t for them and leave. Instead of naming your writer site your name and making your tagline “musings about the writing life” or something else undefined, think about using these to help attract the exact clients you want.
  4. No About page. The About page is a very important part of your writer website. It’s where clients go to get a sense of your personality and who you are as a writer — what you enjoy writing and who you’ve written for. If you don’t have one, I think your site is some kind of Third World scam place.
  5. No clips. I see too many sites where there are no clips at all. My experience is the number-one thing prospects come to your writer site to do is to read your previous work to see if they like it. If you have no clips, they give up and leave. If all you have is your blog posts, link to those! If you have a lot of clips, get up as many as you can. And make them easy to view, not PDFs people have to download. (You can use the Google docs embedder plugin to serve them from a page of your site, among other alternatives.) Since they don’t know and trust you yet, they won’t click that ‘download’ button, and it’s as good as not having anything up. Don’t be mysterious about who you wrote for or what the topic of each piece is, either — indicate the market next to each clip headline so prospects can scan down and see what you write about and where you’ve been published.
  6. No first person. Many writers want to talk about themselves in the third person, as in “Carol Tice has been a freelance writer for more than 15 years, and her work has appeared in…” The problem is this comes off pretty silly online. We all know you wrote it. Also, you’re missing an opportunity to connect with visitors on a personal level by honestly telling your story in the first person.
  7. Too many choices. Some sites are cluttered up with dozens of things — links to writer groups you belong to, ad banners, 10 different social-media buttons, drop-down menus that offer 50 different selections, three sidebars including one on the left or the bottom…it’s all too much. When site visitors are confronted with too many options, they tend to take none and just leave. So keep it simple and remember what you want them to do.
  8. Lukewarm copy. I have seen writers who have done work for Fortune 500 clients, and their copy about their own writing services puts you right to sleep. What writers don’t understand is that the writing on your writer site is an audition piece for getting gigs. Particularly if you don’t have a lot of clips, make this shine. Why should a business believe you can persuade people to buy their product or service if you can’t make your own website copy sparkle?
  9. No testimonials. Study after study has shown that hearing you’re talented from the mouths of your clients is extremely persuasive. You can take LinkedIn recommendations you got and just copy and past them right over here, you know?
  10. Pretending to be something you’re not. Recently, I’ve seen several sites where a solo writer is pretending to be an advertising or marketing agency. Realize that if you say “We specialize in technology projects,” that you are essentially lying about what you can offer. If there is no staff behind the curtain, don’t pretend you have one.

What shape is your writer website in? Leave us a link and we’ll check it out.

Join my freelance writer community. Makealivingwriting.com

46 comments on “The 10-Step Guide to Fixing the Writer Website Fails That Cost You Clients

  1. neal pritchett on

    I am an IT professional, and have had a web site up since the 1990’s. I have been freelancing for a couple of years, and am only just now setting up a professional writer’s web page. So I work all day on computers, networks, and supporting users, including the support of web pages; but have no web presence as a writer. Typically, when asked for writing samples or other such things, I would refer people to my regular website, which is a personal page and covers my hobbies, interests, and travels; but really has nothing writing specific. It’s easy to overlook sometimes, that your writer presence should be just that – a writer presence, and not just as an afterthought on a larger page.

    • Carol Tice on

      Hi Neal — Well, I believe it will definitely get you more clients when you’ve got a focused page. 😉

      FYI, if you’d like to leave a link to a post or page in future, please use our CommentLuv feature — I don’t allow writers to throw in self-promotional links in the body of blog posts. Thanks!

    • Carol Tice on

      You’d be surprised how many writer websites I see that don’t have an About, so don’t feel bad!

      Coming up in September I’ll be doing a whole bootcamp on writer websites, and how to write your Home and About pages…so stay tuned for that.

  2. Concetta on

    Hmm it appears like your website ate my first comment (it was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog.

    I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to everything. Do you have any tips and hints for newbie blog writers? I’d really appreciate
    it.
    Concetta recently posted…ConcettaMy Profile

  3. Joe O. on

    Thank you for not using CAPTCHA or making me pick from various social profiles! The less I have to do to leave comments, the more compelled I feel to participate.

    Excellent post. My only question has to do with writers who want a professional presence for clients and a presence for their fiction writing. I have done development work in the nonprofit sector and now do freelance work in that area, but in my personal time I write horror. I don’t think my clients would be impressed with my depiction of creepy dolls, demonic possessions and other moonlit musings. I feel like I have to keep two websites to keep things separate, but is there a polished way to pull it off?

    In my personal site I have a tab for Consulting, where I reprinted my services through my freelance company. I think it may look out of place, but I wonder if there are potential clients I could snag at one site that I may have missed with the other.

    Thank you for all your excellent advice.
    Joe O. recently posted…Interview Questions for Nonprofit Job SeekersMy Profile

    • Carol Tice on

      Hi Joe –

      I’m with you — when you write fiction it should be a separate site. I think nothing makes prospects run for the hills like hearing you’d really rather be working on your novel. That may be totally true…but it’s just not information you have to give THEM.

    • Carol Tice on

      How often do you fill those out? And when you do, how often do you get a prompt response?

      Unfortunately, contact forms have a bad reputation. They’re not very transparent, and we don’t trust that someone really reads them. So why would you want to have one?

  4. Jan on

    The points you mentioned are spot on. I see blogs/websites that have beautiful themes but no quality content or are missing these things you mentioned.

  5. Kristen on

    I’m in the process on working on implementing many of the changes I’ve seen you recommend here and elsewhere for writer websites.

    I do have a question about #6 though. As someone with a relatively common name, I feel like third person writing, if only on my about page, can help bring my site up in the rankings for anyone googling my name itself.

    Now, I recognize that usually by the time someone knows my name to google, they probably won’t have too hard of a time getting to my information, but I do want it to be as easy as possible for someone already interested in me to find me. Do you think the potential SEO benefit of using your name in the on page copy is undercut by coming off as less personal?

    • Carol Tice on

      I once had a writer proudly tell me they had done a lot of SEO work and now ranked #1 on a search for their name.

      I had to sadly inform them that this was a total waste of time. What you want is to rank for “Seattle freelance writer” (try that and see what happens) or “Arizona healthcare writer” or some other popular, relevant key word phrase. So you can get found by all the people who need the kind of writer you are, as opposed to the three dozen people who know how to spell your name.

      And in general, don’t sacrifice your authenticity because you think it will help you with SEO. That’s. Not. Going. To. Help.

    • Carol Tice on

      Hi Jeremiah — not totally sure the Den is a fit for you — we’re not a bidding marketplace as you’re describing, we’re a learning and support community for freelance writers.

      If you’re looking for writers to hire, feel free to email me a job listing though, and if the pay is appropriate I’m happy to post it in our Den Junk-Free Job Board.

  6. Emma Goldsmith on

    All of this applies to freelance translators’s websites too. It’s so important to write in the first person and not pretend there’s a big team behind you.
    Also, don’t let any typos slip through. Check and re-check everything you write.

  7. Rob Schneider on

    Great article as usual. The Google docs embedder came as a revelation to me. Just last week I spent about half an hour trying to figure out how to do that and finally gave up. I used to use my Dropbox public folder, but learned that Dropbox tells my readers that there’s been too much activity and it is no longer available. I wish they’d told me first.
    Rob Schneider recently posted…Putting Grammarly to the Test ContinuedMy Profile

  8. Terr on

    This was a great and timely post. I saw a few things that I need to tweak. Let me add a pet peeve that you’ve left off.

    Don’t monetize your site. This ties into point #7 (Too many choices). To me, a professional freelancing site should NEVER look like an affiliate marketing site. This means no Adsense, no affiliate marketing buttons or banners, etc. I know of a writer who has a site that is part freelance marketing, part affiliate marketing, part online journal.

    I looked at it and I thought, SERIOUSLY?

    • Carol Tice on

      Hi Terr — you brought up a good point. I also see many writer portfolio sites with ads slapped up and like…what’s that about? Few are driving any substantial traffic to the point where an ad strategy would make any sense — it just sort of advertises that you don’t know how earning on the Internet works.

      And obviously it’s a major pushback for a client — it feels like you don’t really want clients, you want to monetize your own site and earn that way. You certainly can do both — I do — but keep them separate on two different sites. Your writer site shouldn’t have ads.

  9. Alissa Johnson on

    Thank you, thank you! While I’m sure I have a long way to go, my web site has made great strides forward in large part thanks to information I’ve found on your web site. This latest post helped me solve a lingering problem–PDFs of clips.

  10. LindaH on

    As I read through your blog I did my mental checklisst of, “Yep, have that,” or “Need to update that and fix that.” It’s good to review the website. And as your workload gets bigger it’s still important to make time to update the website and keep it fresh and inviting for readers to spend time reviewing.

    No. 11 is important, especially checking the links to ensure they aren’t broken. I found and fixed some broken links that made a lot of difference in search engine rankings and readability. I want to ensure my clients and potential clients get the absolute best from my website. After reading today’s blog I’ll make sure to spend time each week updating and reviewing my website to ensure it’s working and gives my readers the absolute best available content I can provide.

    Great post, Carol, as always. I’ll be refering to this one often to ensure I’m on top of my website and all that I offer my clients.

  11. M. Sharon Baker on

    Carol,

    I’d like to second No. 11, continuously updating. I just sent a prospect to two links that are dead, and found 7 more dead links in the process. So while you are linking, make sure you turn the page into a PDF or save it as web page in your own archive as you may need to find it later.

    I’m also revamping copy, my client list – structuring it different – and finally figuring out how to make a navigation bar with droploads, which I didn’t do initially because I just wanted to get the site up.

    So here I am four years later revamping, in part due to my analytics.

    Also, you may want to rethink the PDF issue – times have changed.

    Newer versions of Acrobat are making PDFs faster, searchable for SEO, and keywords can be added to the discription.

    There’s even a button that optimizes the PDF for the web, making it faster to download.

    Converting some articles, especially those with lots of photos or graphics, into web pages is hard because they look funny and grab navigation or ads.

    I have noticed in a lot of the web research I’m doing that PDFs are coming up very often, and they load fast, so there’s no huge need to convert them to web pages.
    M. Sharon Baker recently posted…5 Email Newsletter Tips from Chris BroganMy Profile

  12. J. Delancy on

    I’m guilty on multiple counts of the indictment. Number 11 on this list would be, ‘failing to improve the site once its up.” It’s startling how many writers will spend big dollars on upgrading their skills, but won’t upgrade their sites with just a little time investment. Yes, I’m guilty of that as well.
    J. Delancy recently posted…7 Ways To Get LuckyMy Profile

    • Carol Tice on

      You bring up a good point. I’ve had a lot of writers ask me, “But when did you consider your site ‘done’?” To which I always reply, “What makes you think I’m happy with the way it is NOW, after 4 years of working on it?”

      Our writer sites and blogs should always be a work in progress. A revamp at least every couple years is good. Speaking of that, watch for some cool new stuff coming to this blog next month, actually…

  13. Katherine Swarts on

    On #2, there is one thing worse than a Contact page that provides “only that horrid fill-in contact form”–and that is a Contact page that provides only a phone number that, when dialed, leads to a lengthy phone menu and ultimately to a voice mailbox with only a department name attached. Not that most freelance writers will have a big enough operation to require departments; but posting the phone number alone is still a strike against you for two reasons: many people who are searching online want to inquire online rather than interrupt themselves to reach for a phone; and many people today associate phone-number contacts (those labeled for anything except personal cell phones, anyway) with voice mail recordings that promise to return calls but never do.
    Katherine Swarts recently posted…One Little Letter Makes a DifferenceMy Profile

  14. Samar on

    It took me a long time to get my website to look professional. I tested a lot of things and most of them bombed. Thankfully, I seem to have found a happy medium.

    Ever since I’ve set up a Testimonials, Portfolio & Hire Me page, work queries have picked up and a lot of them turn into clients because they’ve already seen my work in my portfolio.

    That said, I need to work on my About page though!
    Samar recently posted…How to Impress the Socks Off Your Client Before Writing a Single Word for ThemMy Profile

    • Carol Tice on

      You’re not the only one. It’s funny, but even copywriters I work with seem to have trouble talking about themselves on that page! But it’s worth taking some time to write — and rewrite — it. I try to rewrite mine at least once a year, because I’ve learned more, done more client work…who I am is changing. You want to keep it fresh and personal and up to date. And creative, of course!

    • Carol Tice on

      Isn’t it great? I gather it’s one of about 3 different ways you can solve the problem of not making prospects download your PDFs, but since I understand plugins, it’s the one I gravitated to. This summer hoping to have my teen sit down with my own writer site and fix all my PDFs!

  15. John Soares on

    First off, you do a great job inside the Den of helping freelance writers improve their websites.

    Back to the specific topic of the post, I’ve also seen these same problems. I’ll be running a post later this summer about how I spent 15 minutes trying to let a fellow freelancer know about a great ongoing writing gig that paid very well that was absolutely perfect for this writer. I’ll spare you all the details, but I had a hell of a time even finding the contact page, and I finally quit after being unable to correctly type the Capcha thingie several times.
    John Soares recently posted…Why I Am Changing the Productive Writers Posting Schedule for SummerMy Profile

    • Carol Tice on

      Hi John — makes you feel sad, doesn’t it?

      Everyone should look at their site and identify all the “pushbacks” — points at which a client might get discouraged or frustrated and give up trying to get in touch. Captcha is certainly WAY up there on the list. Just put up with the spam…it’s worth it to get the clients easily emailing you.

Comments are closed.